Torrid Tales Two More True Crime in St. Augustine

Exploring the darker side of St. Augustine has never been more intriguing than with the Torrid Tales Two More True Crime tour. This guided experience offers a rare peek into some of the city’s lesser-known and chilling stories, often at the very spots where tragic events unfolded. Perfect for true crime enthusiasts or history buffs looking for a different perspective on this charming town, this tour combines storytelling with a sense of authenticity that’s hard to find elsewhere.

What sets this tour apart are three key aspects: First, it takes you to actual locations where crimes occurred, making the stories more tangible. Second, the guide provides detailed insights into cases that aren’t common knowledge or extensively discussed, giving you fresh perspectives. Third, at only $30 per person and lasting around 1.5 hours, it offers good value for a unique and engaging experience.

A potential consideration is that the tour’s limited duration means some stories are touched on rather than deeply explored. If you’re craving an in-depth historical analysis, this might feel a bit light. Also, it’s scheduled for the evening, so you’ll want to dress comfortably and be prepared for the dark, which adds to the thrill but might not suit everyone.

This tour is best suited for adults, true crime fans, or those with an interest in ghost stories and local legends. It’s ideal for travelers who prefer storytelling in a relaxed, small-group setting with an emphasis on authenticity.

Good To Know

• Authentic locations: Walk in the footsteps of real victims at the spots where incidents occurred.
• Unique stories: Covers lesser-known cases not typically highlighted in other tours.
• Compact yet engaging: Lasts approximately 1 hour 30 minutes, making it a perfect evening activity.
• Small group size: Max 12 travelers, ensuring personalized attention.
• Certified guide: Led by a licensed, city-certified guide who knows the ins and outs of local lore.
• Value for money: At $30, it offers an affordable way to explore a different side of St. Augustine.

An In-Depth Look at the Torrid Tales True Crime Tour

Starting Point: Ripley’s Bayfront Mini Golf

The tour kicks off at Ripley’s Bayfront Mini Golf, a casual and recognizable spot on Avenida Menendez. Here, the guide introduces the theme and sets the tone with a brief overview of the dark stories you’re about to explore. This initial stop acts as a warm-up, with the guide hinting at the kinds of cases you’ll learn about, teasing a mix of ghostly whispers and real-life tragedies.

What you can expect: The guide is likely to provide context on the tour’s focus on true crime stories, emphasizing the importance of respecting the victims and the historical relevance of the locations. While the mini golf area itself isn’t part of the crime stories, it’s a comfortable starting point that’s easy to find and convenient.

Stop 2: Bridge Street & Marine Street

Next, the group moves through Bridge Street and Marine Street, where two stories unfold. These locations are central to the second case, and the guide points out specific landmarks linked to the incidents. Expect lively narration about local figures involved and the circumstances of their tragedy.

Highlights: The stories here are seldom discussed elsewhere, which gives the tour a special edge. Reviewers have appreciated the way the guide weaves local history with chilling details, saying, “We loved the way the stories were connected to real places we walk by every day.” The walkable nature of the area allows for some stops and discussions, making it feel intimate.

Stop 3: Plaza de la Constitución & The Cathedral

The next section takes you to Plaza de la Constitución, a bustling, picturesque part of town. Here, the tour dives into a story linked to the nearby Cathedral—a site that, despite its serenity today, harbors stories of violence and loss.

Expectations: You may hear about victims involved with the cathedral or its surrounding buildings. The guide’s narrative is likely to include factual recounts, blending history with haunting tales. The setting offers a contrasting backdrop — lively and colorful during the day, but eerily quiet during the tour, amplifying the storytelling experience.

Final Stops: Flagler College & Surroundings

The tour concludes near Flagler College, a historic site with beautiful architecture and a storied past. When discussing the last cases, the guide references areas around Cordova Street and Treasury Street, wrapping up the evening with stories that are both gripping and atmospheric.

What travelers noted: The stories set in this area often include elements of mystery and tragedy, leaving a lasting impression. Reviewers mention that the ending area’s ambiance adds a layer of suspense, making the stories feel more visceral.

What’s Included & What’s Not

Included:

• A licensed, city-certified tour guide who’s well-versed in local lore and crime stories.
• The tour is conducted via mobile ticket, making check-in straightforward.

Not included:

• Gratuity isn’t covered, so if you enjoyed the experience, consider tipping the guide — they generally do a good job with storytelling and engaging the group.

Meeting & End Points

The tour starts at 111 Avenida Menendez and ends near Flagler College at 74 King St, close to the parking lot at Cordova and Treasury Streets. It’s a convenient walkable route through St. Augustine’s historic district. The 8:30 pm start time makes it an atmospheric evening activity, perfect for those looking to explore the city’s darker stories after sunset.

Additional Info & Flexibility

You’ll receive confirmation at booking, and the tour is accessible for most travelers, including service animals. With a maximum of 12 participants, it promises an intimate experience with personalized attention from the guide. The weather can impact the tour, so a clear night will ensure the stories are delivered in the best setting.

The Authenticity & Value of This Tour

This tour’s strength is its authenticity—stories are rooted in real locations, and the guide shares details that aren’t typically part of mainstream tourism. The storytelling style is engaging but balanced, so you’re not overwhelmed with sensationalism. Instead, you get a nuanced understanding of the darker moments in St. Augustine’s past.

For just $30, the tour offers a lot of value. It’s a short but immersive experience that complements other daytime sightseeing activities. You get to learn about real victims, some of whom met tragic ends on the very streets you walk every day, giving you a new perspective on the city’s historic beauty.

Reviewers highlight that the guide’s knowledge and storytelling skills make it worthwhile, with some noting particularly engaging anecdotes and attention to detail. The small group size fosters a comfortable environment to ask questions and engage with the stories.

Who Would Enjoy This Experience?

This tour is well-suited for adults and older teens who enjoy true crime stories and history. It’s perfect for those looking for a slightly spooky, atmospheric activity after a day of sightseeing. People interested in ghost stories, local legends, or dark history will find this especially compelling.

If you prefer deep dives into history or want a more lighthearted experience, this might not meet your expectations. Still, for a quick, atmospheric taste of St. Augustine’s mysterious past, it hits the mark.

FAQ

Is this tour suitable for children?
The tour is geared towards adults and older teens due to the nature of true crime stories. Younger children might find the content too intense or not appropriate.

How long does the tour last?
It lasts approximately 1 hour 30 minutes, making it a manageable evening activity without overcommitting.

Do I need to prepare or bring anything?
Comfortable walking shoes and a warm layer are recommended, as the tour is outdoors and in the evening. No specific preparation is required.

Can I join if I have mobility issues?
Since the tour involves walking through historic streets and outdoor locations, mobility considerations should be checked with the provider for accommodations.

Is it a guided walking tour?
Yes, it’s a walking tour led by a licensed, city-certified guide who shares stories at each stop.

Are the stories graphic or frightening?
The stories are told with respect and aim to be engaging rather than overly gruesome. However, some details of crimes may be unsettling for sensitive guests.

What if the weather is bad?
The tour requires good weather. If canceled due to rain or storms, you can reschedule or receive a full refund.

How many people participate in each tour?
A maximum of 12 travelers ensures a small, intimate group with personalized narration.

Will I get to see actual crime scenes?
You will visit locations associated with the stories, but not crime scenes themselves. The focus is on storytelling and the history of the incidents.

The Torrid Tales Two More True Crime in St. Augustine tour offers a compelling blend of history, mystery, and local lore. It’s a smart choice for travelers seeking a different, more atmospheric perspective of this historic city. With authentic stories, engaging guides, and a comfortable size, it provides a memorable way to explore St. Augustine’s darker past—perfect for an evening adventure that’s both fun and thought-provoking.