In the shadowy streets of New York City, where secrets were whispered and power was traded, a hidden world thrived. It was a world of organized crime, where the Mafia reigned supreme.
Now, imagine stepping into this underworld, guided by retired NYPD Detectives and Police Officers who lived and breathed the city’s criminal history. But this tour offers more than just a glimpse into the dark side of New York City; it also promises a culinary adventure through the heart of Little Italy.
Brace yourself for a journey that will both tantalize your taste buds and immerse you in the captivating lore of the city’s notorious Mafia.
Good To Know

- The tour is led by retired NYPD Detectives and Police Officers with insider knowledge of the NYC Mafia.
- Participants will visit authentic, historic local joints for delicious Italian food.
- The experience offers a unique combination of Mafia history, crime stories, and local food.
- Guides have consulted for TV and major film productions on crime and law enforcement, providing a one-of-a-kind experience.
Mafia Red Sauce Joint: A Historic Starting Point

The Mafia Red Sauce Joint, known as Johns of 12th Street est 1908, serves as the historic starting point for the New York City Mafia Experience & Local Food tour. Stepping inside this iconic hotel is like taking a trip back in time, as the walls are adorned with photographs showcasing the joint’s rich Mafia red sauce joint history.
The menu is a delightful mix of classic Italian dishes that have been passed down through generations. From hearty spaghetti and meatballs to creamy fresh mozzarella, every bite is a taste of Little Italy’s culinary heritage. And let’s not forget the irresistible Sicilian cannoli, a sweet treat that perfectly complements the savory flavors of the main course.
At Johns of 12th Street, visitors can enjoy the ambiance of old-school New York while indulging in mouthwatering dishes that have stood the test of time.
Enjoying the local flavors? More New York City food experiences we've written about
Exploring the East Village and Little Italy

After starting the tour at the iconic Mafia Red Sauce Joint, visitors are ready to embark on a captivating journey through the vibrant streets of the East Village and Little Italy.
- Enjoy the rich history and cultural significance of Little Italy, once the epicenter of NYC Mafia activity.
- Explore the narrow, bustling streets lined with old-world charm and local businesses that have been a part of the neighborhood for generations.
- Learn about the connections between the Mafia and these local businesses, from traditional Italian restaurants to family-owned shops.
- Discover the hidden secrets and stories behind notorious Mafia hangouts and crime locations in the area.
- Indulge in the flavors of Italy as you savor delicious Italian dishes, such as Spaghetti & Meatballs, Fresh Mozzarella, Eggplant Parmesan, and Sicilian Cannoli, at authentic, historic local joints.
As you wander through the East Village and Little Italy, you’ll feel the energy and history come alive, gaining a deeper understanding of the neighborhood’s past and present.
Indulging in Authentic Italian Cuisine

Savor the flavors of authentic Italian cuisine as you embark on a culinary journey through the vibrant streets of the East Village and Little Italy. Enjoy the rich and diverse Italian culture as you sample traditional Italian dishes that have been perfected over generations.
The tour takes you to authentic, historic local joints where you can indulge in a feast fit for a king. From the classic Spaghetti & Meatball to the creamy Fresh Mozzarella and the mouthwatering Eggplant Parm, every bite is a celebration of the Italian culinary heritage.
And don’t forget to save room for the sweet finale – the Sicilian Cannoli, a crispy pastry shell filled with delectable sweet ricotta cheese.
As you savor each dish, you’ll not only satisfy your taste buds but also gain a deeper understanding of Italian culture and its influence on New York City’s culinary scene.
Insights From Retired NYPD Detectives

Led by retired NYPD Detectives and Police Officers, this experience offers a unique tour of the NYC Mafia, providing insider perspectives and insights into the city’s underworld. Participants will have the opportunity to hear firsthand accounts from these retired detectives, who’ve spent their careers investigating and combating organized crime.
Here are five key insights that visitors can expect to gain from the retired NYPD detectives’ perspective:
A deep understanding of the Mafia’s history in New York City, including its origins, rise to power, and eventual decline.
Fascinating crime stories that showcase the intricate webs of power, betrayal, and violence that characterized the Mafia’s operations.
Insider knowledge about key figures and families within the Mafia, shedding light on their influence and impact on the city.
An exploration of notorious Mafia hangouts and crime locations, providing a glimpse into the dark underbelly of New York’s gangland.
Valuable insights into the methods and strategies employed by law enforcement to combat organized crime, showcasing the ongoing battle between the police and the Mafia.
With these insights, participants can expect a truly immersive and eye-opening experience into the fascinating world of the NYC Mafia.
More Great Thing To Do NearbyUnveiling Notorious Mafia and Crime Locations

As participants explore the world of the NYC Mafia with retired NYPD Detectives, they’re taken on a captivating journey that unveils the notorious locations intertwined with the city’s criminal underworld.
This immersive experience sheds light on the dark history of organized crime in New York City and its impact on local communities.
From the bustling streets of the East Village to the vibrant neighborhood of Little Italy, you will walk in the footsteps of infamous mobsters and learn about the illicit activities that once plagued these areas.
The guides, who’ve firsthand knowledge and experience, reveal the secrets and stories behind these locations, providing a unique perspective on the Mafia history in New York City.
This exploration of the city’s criminal past offers a fascinating insight into the lasting effects of organized crime on the communities it once controlled.
More tours and activities we've covered in New York City
Taking in the Dramatic Gangland of NYC

Enjoy the dramatic gangland of NYC as you journey through the hidden corners and notorious haunts that once served as the backdrop for the city’s underworld activities.
- Discover the dark secrets that lurk beneath the surface of the bustling city.
- Explore hidden mafia landmarks and uncover the stories behind them.
- Feel the adrenaline rush as you walk in the footsteps of infamous mobsters.
- Experience the thrill of being transported back in time to a world of organized crime.
- Be captivated by the tales of power, betrayal, and survival that define the city’s criminal history.
The underworld secrets of New York City come alive as you explore the shadows of the city’s past. From the back alleys of Little Italy to the hidden speakeasies of the East Village, every step reveals a new layer of intrigue.
Enjoy the dramatic gangland of NYC and let the stories of the infamous mafia unfold before your eyes.
Common Questions

What Is the Cost of the ‘New York City Mafia Experience & Local Food: W/ NYPD Guide’ Tour?
The cost of the tour includes local Italian foods, a guided experience with retired NYPD detectives, and insider knowledge of the NYC Mafia. Children can participate in this unique tour for a truly immersive experience.
Can Children Participate in the Tour?
Yes, children can participate in the tour. It is suitable for kids, providing an engaging and informative experience. They will learn about the NYC Mafia and enjoy delicious Italian food while accompanied by retired NYPD Detectives and Police Officers.
Is Transportation Provided During the Tour?
Transportation is not provided during the tour. Participants are responsible for their own transportation to and from the meeting point. The tour cost covers the guided experience and the delicious local Italian food.
Are Vegetarian or Vegan Food Options Available During the Tour?
Vegetarian and vegan food options are available during the tour, ensuring that all dietary preferences are accommodated. The knowledgeable guides can recommend vegetarian and vegan restaurants in NYC for those looking to explore the city’s culinary scene.
What Is the Maximum Group Size for the Tour?
The maximum group size for the tour is not specified. However, tour availability can be checked to see if there are any restrictions or limitations on group size.
The Sum Up

In the bustling streets of New York City, the New York City Mafia Experience & Local Food tour offers a truly unique adventure.
Led by retired NYPD Detectives and Police Officers, participants are taken on a journey through the infamous gangland history of the city, while also indulging in mouthwatering Italian cuisine.
With insider knowledge and captivating storytelling, this tour promises an unforgettable experience for history enthusiasts, food lovers, and those seeking a one-of-a-kind adventure.
Don’t miss the opportunity to learn about the dramatic world of the NYC Mafia.
You can check if your dates are available here:More Food Tours in New York City
More Food & Drink Tours in New York City
More Tour Reviews in New York City
- True Crime New York: NYPD-Guided Mafia Walking Tour w/ Food
- Upper West Side NYC Architecture Walking Tour
- Upper and Lower Manhattan Tour
- VIP Private New York City Tour Intimate Group of 10pax Max
- Visit the Lower East Side – the soul of Manhattan with Guillaume
- Wall Street: The birth place of NYC in French/English tour
Looking for something different? Other New York City activities we've written about
- True Crime New York: NYPD-Guided Mafia Walking Tour w/ Food
- Upper West Side NYC Architecture Walking Tour
- Upper and Lower Manhattan Tour
- VIP Private New York City Tour Intimate Group of 10pax Max
- Visit the Lower East Side – the soul of Manhattan with Guillaume
- Wall Street: The birth place of NYC in French/English tour
- Wall Street Insider Tour with a Finance Professional
- Walking tour of the Brooklyn Bridge and Dumbo
- Washington DC from New York 1 Day
- Washington Heights to Sugar Hill North Walking Tour
- Washington DC: Washington Monument Top View Reserved Entry
- New York City: Private Walking Tour with a Local
