New Jersey New Year’s Eve Buffet Dinner Cruise

Planning a New Year’s Eve celebration often means deciding between crowded parties, loud bars, or quieter moments at home. A dinner cruise on the Hudson River promises a unique blend of scenic views, entertainment, and festive cheer—but does it deliver? This review looks closely at the New Jersey New Year’s Eve Buffet Dinner Cruise offered by City Cruises, weighing the pros and cons based on available information and one existing guest review.

What we like about this experience includes breathtaking skyline views of Manhattan, Brooklyn, and New Jersey, a chef-prepared buffet meant to satisfy different tastes, and the chance to ring in the new year with fireworks over the river. The open bar with premium spirits is also a tempting perk, allowing for a celebratory toast. However, some potential drawbacks include the limited food options, reportedly lackluster service, and fogged-up windows obstructing views from certain areas—crucial factors when you’re paying premium prices.

This cruise could work well for travelers seeking a festive, scenic way to celebrate NYE without the chaos of land-based parties. Those who prioritize spectacular views and a lively atmosphere might find this a memorable evening, but if excellent food and attentive service are top priorities, you’ll want to weigh those aspects carefully.

Good To Know

• Scenic Views: Offers unobstructed views of iconic NYC landmarks and fireworks.
• Value for Price: At $650, the cruise includes a buffet, open bar, and entertainment but may fall short on food quality.
• Limited Food Quality (Reported): Some guests found the buffet and desserts underwhelming.
• Atmosphere & Entertainment: DJ music and themed props enhance the party vibe.
• Potential Visibility Issues: Fogged windows and limited vantage points could detract from the experience.
• Best For: Those seeking skyline views, a festive ambiance, and a celebration on the water.

Setting Sail: What to Expect

The Itinerary and Key Stops

The cruise departs from 1500 Harbor Blvd, Weehawken, at 10:00 pm, giving you plenty of time to enjoy the evening’s festivities. The boat promises a three-hour celebration packed with dining, dancing, and awe-inspiring sights. A significant highlight is the chance to see the Statue of Liberty, Brooklyn Bridge, and One World Trade Center, all from the comfort of the deck. Guests can take photos and admire these landmarks illuminated against the night sky, creating lasting memories.

The stops are more about the views than actual sightseeing excursions; there’s no time allocated for disembarking or exploring these landmarks. Instead, they serve as scenic backdrops for your evening, with the cruise providing unobstructed vantage points—assuming windows aren’t fogged up, as some guests have experienced.

Dining and Beverage Offerings

The centerpiece of this cruise is the chef-prepared buffet-style dinner. While the menu isn’t specified, it’s reasonable to assume it offers a variety of options suited to a broad audience. However, a guest reviewer, Timothy_R, described the food as “meh,” with desserts like off-brand Chips Ahoy cookies that seemed more like leftovers than gourmet treats. Service was reportedly non-existent, especially on the lower level where fogged windows hampered the view.

The top-shelf open bar is a definite plus for those looking to indulge, with the “Silver Package” including this feature. Complimentary drinks like coffee, hot tea, juice, and soda are also provided, ensuring guests stay refreshed. The onboard DJ and themed props (hats, beads, noisemakers) contribute to the lively New Year’s atmosphere, encouraging dancing and photo-taking.

The Fireworks & Midnight Toast

A key moment is the fireworks display over the Hudson River—a highlight for many celebrating the New Year. It’s weather-dependent but promises to be spectacular, with the skyline lit up in synchronized bursts. The countdown culminates with a sparkling wine toast (for guests 21+)—a traditional and festive way to mark the moment.

The Pros and Cons

Pros

Unmatched Skyline and Landmark Views: From the deck, you get sweeping, panoramic views of NYC landmarks, perfect for photos and creating a festive mood.

Festive Atmosphere: DJ entertainment, props, and a lively crowd make it feel like a celebration rather than just a dinner.

Convenience: All-in-one experience—dining, dancing, fireworks—so you don’t need to plan multiple events or book separate tickets.

Prime Location: Meeting point in Weehawken is accessible via public transit and close to the city, avoiding long commutes after midnight.

Cons

Food Quality Concerns: The buffet, based on a review, seems underwhelming and might leave some guests disappointed, especially if you’re expecting a gourmet experience.

Limited Visibility & Comfort: Fogged windows and possible congestion on the lower level could interfere with enjoying the scenic views and fireworks.

Price Point: At $650, this cruise isn’t cheap. Given the reported food quality and service, some might feel the experience offers less value for the cost.

Service & Attentiveness: Reports of non-existent service could be frustrating during a rushed, lively event where you want to relax and enjoy.

Who Should Consider This Cruise?

This New Year’s Eve cruise is best suited for travelers who prioritize spectacular skyline views and festive entertainment over gourmet dining. It’s an ideal setting for those who want a fun, visually stunning celebration with a lively party atmosphere, and who are okay with potentially crowded conditions or less-than-stellar food.

If your main goal is a quiet, intimate evening or top-tier cuisine, this cruise may not be the best fit. However, if you’re after the quintessential New York and New Jersey skyline experience with fireworks and a party vibe, it could still be a memorable choice—just manage your expectations around food and service.

Practical Tips for Your Night Out

• Arrive early: To secure your preferred spot and avoid last-minute crowds.
• Dress casually but neat: Khakis, dresses, or nice jeans are suitable—no need for formal attire.
• Bring your camera: Just be aware that fogged windows might hinder photos from certain spots.
• Check the weather forecast: Fireworks depend on clear weather, so stay flexible if conditions aren’t perfect.
• Plan your transportation: The meeting point is accessible via public transit, but consider parking options if driving.

Final Thoughts

The New Jersey New Year’s Eve Buffet Dinner Cruise offers a lively, picturesque way to welcome the new year. Its strength lies in the views, the festive atmosphere, and the fireworks, making it appealing for those wanting a memorable celebration on the water. However, the experience’s value is somewhat weighed down by questionable food quality and mixed reviews on service.

If you’re seeking a fun, scenic, and energetic way to ring in 2024 and aren’t overly concerned about gourmet dining, this cruise could be a good pick. But if you’re after refined cuisine or attentive service, you might want to explore other options or plan for a different celebration.

FAQ

Is the cruise suitable for all travelers?
Most travelers can participate, including those with service animals. It’s a casual event, so comfortable attire suffices.

What is included in the ticket price?
Your ticket includes a three-hour buffet-style dinner, top-shelf open bar, live DJ entertainment, fireworks (weather permitting), and NYE props.

Can I see the fireworks from anywhere on the boat?
The cruise promises unobstructed views, but some guests report fogged windows, especially on the lower level. The deck should be the best spot for fireworks.

How long does the cruise last?
Approximately three hours, starting at 10:00 pm and ending around 1:00 am.

Are drinks included?
Yes, the Silver Package features a top-shelf open bar, with additional complimentary drinks like coffee and soda.

Is the food worth the price?
Based on reviews, the buffet might be underwhelming, with some guests describing it as “meh” and desserts as off-brand snacks. Consider this when deciding whether to splurge on this experience.

To sum it up, this cruise offers a lively, scenic way to celebrate New Year’s Eve but comes with caveats regarding food quality and comfort. It’s best suited for travelers who prioritize the fireworks and skyline views over gourmet dining and are happy to enjoy a festive party atmosphere on the water.