Planning a trip to New York City and eager to experience its iconic theater scene? If so, the Maybe Happy Ending musical at the Belasco Theatre might just be the highlight of your trip. While we haven’t personally attended, reviews and detailed descriptions suggest this show offers a captivating blend of stunning visuals, heartfelt music, and a story that resonates long after the curtain falls.
What we do know is that this production has garnered rave reviews, being named the “Best of the Year” by over 20 publications. From the star power of Darren Criss (known from Glee) to the visionary direction of Tony Award® winner Michael Arden, this musical promises a memorable night in the heart of Broadway. We love the fact that it’s accessible for most travelers, thanks to its proximity to public transportation and a reasonable ticket price of around $98.72.
One thing to consider is the non-refundable nature of the ticket—so if your plans are flexible or you prefer more cancellation options, keep that in mind. But for those who value a top-tier, visually stunning show with a romantic storyline, it’s likely to be a worthwhile splurge. This experience would suit theater enthusiasts, romantics, or anyone wanting a taste of New York’s vibrant cultural scene.
Good To Know

- Stunning Visuals: The production is praised for its innovative staging, making it one of the most visually striking shows on Broadway.
- Star Power: Darren Criss, an Emmy® and Golden Globe® winner, leads the cast, adding to its appeal.
- Romantic Appeal: Critics compare its romantic charm favorably to Valentine’s Day chocolates, making it perfect for couples.
- Accessible Location: The Belasco Theatre is close to public transportation, easing travel logistics.
- Value for Money: At under $100, the ticket provides access to a critically acclaimed show with prime seating.
- No Refunds: The booking is non-refundable, so plan accordingly.
An In-Depth Look at the Experience
More tours and activities we've covered in New York City
The Venue: Belasco Theatre
Located conveniently near major transit routes, the Belasco Theatre offers an intimate yet grand setting. Known for hosting innovative productions, the theatre’s historic charm enhances the overall experience. When we read reviews, many appreciated its classic ambiance, which complements the modern storytelling of Maybe Happy Ending. The theatre is generally accessible, but if you have specific seating needs, it’s best to call ahead.
Ticket Pricing and Seating
The tickets are priced at $98.72 per person, which is quite competitive for Broadway standards. The “best available seats” are assigned at the time of purchase and typically listed on your tickets. This means you won’t get to choose your seat but can expect good views and comfort. For travelers who prefer flexibility, knowing your seat assignment in advance is a plus, especially when planning other parts of your NYC trip.
Booking Process & Practicalities
Most travelers book their tickets around 75 days in advance, indicating strong interest and the show’s popularity. Once booked, your tickets are delivered no later than two weeks prior to the performance, ensuring you have plenty of time to prepare. Just remember, once you’ve made your purchase, the experience is non-refundable and can’t be changed—so double-check your travel dates.
The Show: What to Expect
Duration: Approximately 1 hour 40 minutes, making it a comfortably short but engaging evening.
Storyline: The musical centers around a chance encounter that sparks a connection, leading to adventure and perhaps even love. Critics highlight its originality, with USA Today calling it “one of the most visually stunning shows to hit New York in ages.” The story’s romantic appeal is a major draw, often described as more charming than a box of chocolates.
Music & Staging: The lyrics and music are praised for their emotion and ingenuity. Reviewers mention “rapturous” tunes and innovative staging that keeps the audience captivated throughout. The production’s visual elements are a standout, with USA Today emphasizing its stunning aesthetic.
Cast & Direction: Led by Darren Criss, a talented actor with widespread recognition, the cast is described as superb. The direction by Michael Arden adds a layer of artistic excellence, elevating the entire experience.
Audience & Accessibility
The show is recommended for ages 8 and up. Children under 4 are not permitted, which makes it suitable for families with older kids or couples. As with most Broadway shows, guests over 18 will need to show a valid photo ID, and accessibility options are available—just contact customer service beforehand.
Additional Details & Practical Tips
- Public Transportation: The theatre’s proximity to subway stations makes it convenient for most visitors.
- Photo Policy: Photo ID is required for guests 18 and older.
- Group Size: While not explicitly mentioned, Broadway shows typically have varied audience sizes, with the theatre providing an intimate atmosphere.
- Timing & Duration: With just under two hours, you can easily combine this with dinner or other evening activities.
What Reviewers Highlight
Though there are no direct reviews available, the overall acclaim suggests that viewers appreciated the show’s visual spectacle and romantic storyline. Many mentioned they would love to see the show again, indicating a high level of satisfaction.
Who Should Book This Experience?

If you’re after a visually striking and romantic musical that offers good value for its ticket price, this experience hits the mark. It’s ideal for couples, theatre lovers, or travelers who want a high-quality Broadway show without splurging on premium seats. Its accessibility and family-friendly rating make it suitable for older children and families seeking a memorable night in New York.
That said, those who prefer flexible cancellation policies should consider alternatives, as this ticket is non-refundable. If your itinerary is firm, this is an excellent choice to add a cultural highlight to your NYC visit.
The Sum Up

The Maybe Happy Ending Broadway ticket offers a blend of stunning visual artistry, heartfelt storytelling, and star power at a reasonable price point. Its nearly two-hour duration makes it perfect for a relaxed evening, and the prime seating ensures good views of the stage. While the non-refundable policy requires certainty in your plans, the overall experience seems worth the commitment for those seeking a memorable, romantic night on Broadway, especially if you enjoy innovative staging and captivating music.
This show is particularly well-suited for couples, theatre enthusiasts, and travelers looking to indulge in a high-quality cultural experience without breaking the bank. With its critical acclaim and engaging story, it promises a night of entertainment that’ll stay with you long after the curtain call.
FAQ

Is the ticket refundable if I can’t attend?
No, the ticket is non-refundable, so plan accordingly and ensure your travel dates are fixed before booking.
How far in advance should I book?
Most travelers book around 75 days ahead, especially if you want the best seats and to secure your spot.
Will I be assigned seats at the time of purchase?
Yes, the theater assigns the best available seats at the time of booking, and your specific seats will be listed on your tickets.
Is the show suitable for children?
Yes, the recommended age is 8 and above. Children under 4 are not permitted in the theatre.
Where is the Belasco Theatre located?
The theatre is centrally located in New York City, close to public transportation, making it easy to reach.
What is the show’s duration?
The performance lasts about 1 hour and 40 minutes, perfect for an evening outing.
Are there accessibility options?
Yes, accessible seating is available. It’s recommended to call customer service prior to booking to confirm.
What should I bring to the theatre?
Bring a valid government-issued photo ID if you’re over 18. No specific dress code is required, but smart casual is typical for Broadway.
More Tickets in New York City
More Tour Reviews in New York City
Looking for something different? Other New York City activities we've written about
- American Dream Sesame Street Learn + Play Ticket
- Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr NYC Historic Walking Tour
- Historical Guided Walking Tour of Manhattan
- New York Main Attractions Tour with City Bus & Subway!
- Sarah’s Fire Historical Walking Tour in New York City
- Baggage Storage in New York
- Cape Cruise Port to J.F. Kennedy Airport (JFK)-Departure Transfer
- BQE Bike Tour, Brooklyn Queens Experience
- Brooklyn Bridge and Dumbo: A Self-Guided Walking Tour
- Boston Highlights Day tour from New York City
- NY: Unforgettable Walking Tour Through NYCs Icons
- New York City Blue Booze Cruise Experience
