Lunch at Iconic Redeye Grill near Central Park and Carnegie Hall!

If you’re exploring New York City and craving a sit-down meal that captures the city’s lively yet sophisticated vibe, the Redeye Grill offers a convenient and tasty option. This tour isn’t a typical sightseeing activity—it’s about taking a break, soaking in the city’s energy, and enjoying a well-curated meal in a prime Midtown location.

What makes this experience appealing? First, its central location across from Carnegie Hall means you’re never far from the heart of NYC’s arts and culture scene. Second, the two-course prix-fixe lunch provides a good mix of choices—from seafood to hearty burgers—ensuring everyone finds something they’ll enjoy. Third, for just $41, it offers solid value considering the quality and convenience.

One thing to consider is that this tour is quite structured—so if you’re looking for a free-flowing, leisurely meal, it might feel slightly regimented. Also, it’s primarily designed for weekday lunch hours, so it suits those with a tight schedule or pre-theater plans. It’s perfect for visitors wanting a taste of New York’s culinary style without a hefty price tag, especially if you’re in Midtown for sightseeing or shows.

Good To Know

• Prime Midtown location across from Carnegie Hall makes it easy to combine with sightseeing
• Affordable two-course prix-fixe lunch offers good variety and quality
• Convenient timing during weekday lunch hours (12:00 PM–2:30 PM)
• All-inclusive pricing with gratuities and taxes covered
• Ideal for pre-theater meals, business lunches, or quick Midtown breaks
• Limited alcohol options—only available to guests 21+

An In-Depth Look at the Redeye Grill Lunch Experience

If you’ve ever wandered around Midtown Manhattan during lunchtime, you’ll know how hectic and crowded it can be—especially near Broadway and Carnegie Hall. The Redeye Grill stands out as a welcome oasis of comfort and style, offering a meal that feels both substantial and elegant without requiring hours of planning or a big budget.

Location and Accessibility

Located at 890 7th Ave, directly across from Carnegie Hall, the restaurant’s spot is unbeatable for travelers wanting a break from sightseeing. It’s near public transportation, making it straightforward to reach whether you’re coming from Times Square, Central Park, or nearby theaters. Being in such a central spot also means you’ll have plenty of time to enjoy your meal without the stress of long travel or waiting.

Booking and Timing

Most bookings are made about 16 days in advance, which suggests this is a popular choice for visitors planning their NYC itinerary ahead of time. The experience runs exclusively during weekdays, from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM, aligning nicely with lunch hours. You’ll meet at 890 7th Ave, and the experience concludes back at the same point—no fuss about transportation or additional costs.

What’s Included?

For $41, you get a two-course prix-fixe meal plus a soft drink—either water or fountain soda. Tips and taxes are already included, simplifying the bill and making it easy to budget. The menu features various appetizers and main courses, so you can tailor the meal to your taste—whether you’re craving seafood, a hearty burger, or a veggie-friendly bowl.

Menu Highlights and Choices

The appetizer options include classics like Caesar Salad and Greek Salad, as well as more indulgent choices like Fried Calamari served with yuzu aioli, or a Shrimp Cocktail. These options set the tone for a satisfying meal.

For the main courses, you can choose from a range of hearty and flavorful dishes: the Black Label Cheeseburger with Tillamook cheddar and fries, a lighter Chicken Cobb Salad, or the Grilled Teriyaki Salmon Bowl with spinach and brown rice. Vegetarians aren’t left out, with choices like the Vegetarian Teriyaki Bowl featuring roasted peppers, mushrooms, and bok choy.

Authenticity and Quality

From reviews, it’s clear that the quality of the food and the service tend to meet or exceed expectations. Guests appreciate that the menu offers a good balance between familiar comfort foods and fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The ambiance strikes a balance between relaxed and refined, making it suitable whether you’re on a business lunch or a leisurely break.

The Dining Experience

Guests have shared that the service is attentive and the atmosphere is lively but not loud—ideal for conversation. While the experience is structured, it’s flexible enough to accommodate different dining paces. The soft drink inclusion helps keep it casual, though some might wish for a wider beverage selection, especially alcohol options, which are limited to those over 21.

Authentic Insights from Reviewers

One reviewer highlighted the value for money, noting that the $41 price tag feels justified given the quality and location. Others mentioned that timing is key—arriving slightly earlier or later during the lunch window helps avoid the busiest rush. Several also appreciated the close proximity to Broadway theaters, making it a perfect pre-show spot.

Practical Details and Tips

• Reservation recommended—especially during peak weeks, to secure a spot.
• The experience is limited to groups of up to 10 travelers, maintaining a cozy, personal vibe.
• Make sure to arrive on time, as the lunch window is strictly between 12:00 PM–2:30 PM.
• If you’re planning to visit nearby attractions or catch a show, this meal fits well into a tight schedule.
• Expect a relaxed but efficient service—the staff is known to be friendly and quick.

Who Will Love This Experience?

This lunch experience is best suited for travelers seeking a convenient, high-quality meal in Midtown Manhattan without breaking the bank. It’s ideal for pre-theater goers, business travelers needing a quick yet refined lunch, or travelers in need of a sit-down break during busy sightseeing days. If you’re after a casual, authentic NYC dining experience in a prime location, this is a solid choice.

The Sum Up

In short, the Redeye Grill lunch offers a straightforward, enjoyable way to pause your busy NYC day. Its central location, value-packed menu, and comfortable setting make it a smart pick for those wanting a taste of New York’s classic brasserie style without a hefty price tag.

While the limited menu and structured timing might not suit those looking for a long, leisurely meal or diverse beverage options, it’s perfect if you’re after a reliable, tasty meal close to Broadway and Carnegie Hall. Whether you’re visiting for a quick break, a pre-show dinner, or just want to enjoy a slice of NYC’s culinary scene, this experience delivers a lot of bang for your buck.

FAQs

Is the lunch available on weekends?
No, this experience runs only Monday through Friday from 12:00 PM to 2:30 PM.

How much does the meal cost?
The two-course prix-fixe lunch costs $41 per person, including gratuities and taxes.

What’s included in the price?
You get a starter and main course, plus a soft drink. Gratuities and government fees are also included.

Can I order alcohol?
Alcoholic beverages are available only for guests 21 and over, but they are not included in the package price.

What if I need to cancel?
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, making it flexible for unforeseen plans.

Is there a group size limit?
Yes, the maximum group size is 10 travelers, maintaining an intimate dining setting.

Where exactly do we meet?
The meeting point is 890 7th Ave, New York, NY 10106, near public transportation and easily accessible.

Are there vegetarian options?
Yes, vegetarian options like the Vegetarian Teriyaki Bowl are available on the menu.

How long is the dining experience?
It lasts approximately 1 hour 30 minutes, fitting well into a busy sightseeing schedule.

Is it suitable for families or only adults?
While the menu is adult-oriented, families with older children can enjoy the experience, but note that alcohol is only for those 21+.

This lunch at Redeye Grill provides an authentic taste of NYC’s dining scene with great location, solid menu choices, and good value—making it a worthwhile addition to your Midtown adventures.