Chicago Gangsters: Self-Guided Crime Story Puzzle Walk – Review
Taking a walk through Chicago’s storied streets with a puzzle twist sounds intriguing, but does this self-guided experience deliver the kind of adventure you’re hoping for? Based on the available reviews and the detailed itinerary, it’s a mixed bag—some travelers find it a fun way to learn about the city’s architecture and history, while others have faced technical hiccups that dampen the experience.
What we love about this tour is its affordable price point of just over $7 per person, making it accessible for most budgets. The focus on Chicago’s famous landmarks like the Tribune Tower and Water Tower District offers plenty of visual appeal, and the story-driven puzzles add an element of engagement for those who enjoy a bit of brainteasing. Plus, the fact that it’s self-guided means you can go at your own pace—perfect for those who dislike large tour groups or rigid schedules.
However, a notable drawback is the inconsistency in the tech experience—at least one reviewer couldn’t get the app to recognize their code, which can cause frustration. This underscores the importance of having a charged phone and being comfortable with using apps for self-guided tours. Also, since the tour covers a wide area with multiple stops, it’s best suited for those interested in architecture, Chicago’s past, or who enjoy solving puzzles rather than those seeking a highly curated guided experience.
This tour will suit independent explorers with a curiosity for Chicago’s history and architecture who don’t mind a bit of technical troubleshooting. If you’re someone who loves puzzles, discovering historical sights at your own pace, and are okay with some minor inconveniences, this could add a fun layer to your city visit.
Good To Know

- Affordable and flexible: Great value at just $7.51 and no fixed schedule.
- Educational and immersive: Combines architecture, history, and gangster lore.
- Tech-dependent: Requires a smartphone, app download, and a charged device.
- Potential technical issues: Some users report problems with app codes.
- Self-paced exploration: Ideal for independent travelers or puzzle enthusiasts.
- Focus on iconic landmarks: See Chicago’s architectural gems while playing a story.
Deep Dive into the Experience

Interested in exploring Chicago on foot? Other walking tours we've covered
What’s Included and How It Works
This tour is a self-guided puzzle walk that unfolds via a mobile app, guiding you from the starting point at Exchequer Restaurant & Pub through a series of landmarks ending at Holy Name Cathedral. It’s designed to last around 1 to 1.5 hours, but you can take your time—especially if you embrace the architecture and history at each stop.
Once booked, you’ll receive an email with instructions on how to download the Questo app and set up your account. The idea is simple—each player (or group) can share a phone or use separate devices, but generally, one ticket per person is recommended for an optimal experience.
The Itinerary Breakdown
Each stop is allotted roughly nine minutes of exploration time, but this is flexible, and you’re free to linger. Here’s what you can expect at each:
- Start at Exchequer Restaurant & Pub: A bustling spot in downtown Chicago since 1969. It’s a good place to grab a quick bite or just start your journey with some local flavor. This is where your adventure begins, with the app’s first instructions.
- Palmer House Hilton: An architectural marvel with roots dating back to 1871, the hotel’s ornate exterior offers a glimpse into the Gilded Age. It’s a popular picture spot, and many enjoy learning about its history as a landmark.
- Pendry Chicago: A sleek addition to the skyline, this modern hotel contrasts with the historic buildings and adds a contemporary flair to your walk.
- Jewelers Building: Recognized for its neo-Gothic style, this structure sparks curiosity about Chicago’s jewelry trade and architectural past. Many find it visually stunning and historically significant.
- Harry Caray’s Italian Steakhouse: More than just a place to eat, this spot is part of Chicago’s culinary scene. While not part of the puzzle, it makes for a delightful photo op with its lively facade.
- DuSable Bridge: An engineering masterpiece, this double-deck bascule bridge embodies Chicago’s knack for impressive architecture and infrastructure.
- Tribune Tower: With its medieval-inspired façade, it’s a must-see for architecture buffs. Several reviews mention the tower’s grandeur and the detailed stonework, which adds to its allure.
- InterContinental Chicago Magnificent Mile: A historic hotel that’s an excellent example of 1920s architecture, offering a regal look at Chicago’s luxury side.
- Old Chicago Water Tower District: The Water Tower is a symbol of Chicago’s resilience after the Great Fire, and many visitors appreciate stopping here to capture the essence of the city’s survival story.
- Holy Name Cathedral: The final stop features stunning architecture and religious significance, bringing your walk to a meaningful close.
The Puzzle Element and Storytelling
The story of gangsters and Chicago’s rise is crafted by talented writers, adding a layer of intrigue to each landmark. As you solve challenges on your phone, the narrative unfolds, making the history more engaging than a typical sightseeing walk. Unfortunately, the reviews reveal that technical issues can occur—one traveler couldn’t get the email code to work, which is frustrating, especially if you’re excited to start.
The Pros and Cons Based on User Feedback
While some love the interior visits and the chance to get more info from locals during the walk, others have experienced app glitches that undermine the experience. It’s worth noting that the reviewer who was happy mentioned the fun of checking out architecture and learning city history, describing it as a fun way to explore “even your home city.”
Given the experience of others, you should be comfortable with using your phone for navigation and troubleshooting minor tech issues, or be prepared to switch devices if needed. The ability to customize the pace is a plus, but it’s only worthwhile if the app functions smoothly for you.
Like guided experiences? More Chicago tours with local guides
- 2-Hour Guided Segway Tour of Chicago
- Medieval Torture Museum Ticket With Audio Guide and Ghost Hunting
- Skip-the-Line Art Institute of Chicago Exclusive Guided Museum Tour
- Chicago: Guided Tour With Skydeck and Shoreline River Cruise
- Chicago: Private Guided Tour of Chicago Suburbs Movie Sites
- Guided Historic Small Boat River Architecture Tour in Chicago
Duration, Price, and Overall Value
At just over $7, this tour is very budget-friendly, especially considering it offers a personalized story-driven experience rather than a crowded group tour. The timing flexibility allows for a relaxed pace, and the variety of landmarks offers a good overview of Chicago’s architectural and historical highlights.
However, the uneven technical reliability means that if you’re not comfortable troubleshooting or don’t want to risk missing parts of the story, it might be worth considering a guided tour. Still, for independent explorers who enjoy puzzles and urban exploration, this is a creative way to see the city.
Who Will Love This Tour?
If you enjoy self-guided activities that combine history, architecture, and storytelling, this walk has plenty to offer. It’s especially suitable for puzzle lovers and those interested in Chicago’s gangster lore intertwined with iconic sights.
It’s a good fit for travelers who are comfortable with apps and can handle minor technical hiccups. If you prefer guided commentary from a knowledgeable guide or a highly curated experience, this may not be your first choice.
Final Thoughts

This self-guided crime story puzzle walk in Chicago offers a creative way to explore the city’s main landmarks while uncovering its gangster past. With a modest price point and the ability to go at your own speed, it appeals to independent travelers and puzzle enthusiasts alike. The major upside is the chance to learn about Chicago’s architecture and history through an engaging narrative, which makes the sightseeing feel more interactive.
On the flip side, technical issues have been reported, which can dampen the experience if not resolved quickly. If you’re tech-savvy and eager to explore Chicago’s streets with a blend of history and mystery, this tour could add a fun dimension to your trip.
Overall, it’s a cost-effective, flexible, and story-driven way to see the city, perfect for those who love a bit of adventure and don’t mind troubleshooting along the way. For travelers seeking a guided, seamless experience, a more traditional tour might be preferable, but for those wanting to take charge of their exploration, this offers a memorable and unique challenge.
FAQs

Can I do this tour alone or with friends?
You can participate solo or as part of a small group. It’s recommended to purchase one ticket per person for the best experience, but multiple people can share a phone.
What is the duration of the tour?
The estimated time is about 1 to 1.5 hours, though you can extend your visit at each stop if you wish.
Do I need to download any app?
Yes, you must download the Questo app and create an account using the email used at booking prior to starting the tour.
Is the tour suitable for children?
The story and puzzles are generally suitable for older children or teenagers, especially those interested in history and architecture. Keep in mind that the content focuses on Chicago’s gangster past.
Are the landmarks open for visiting?
All landmarks are public outdoor sites or exterior perspectives. Some interior visits are optional and depend on your timing and interest.
What if I experience technical issues?
One reviewer faced challenges with app code recognition. It’s best to ensure your phone is charged, the app is updated, and you follow instructions carefully.
Can I start the tour at any time?
Yes, the tour is available from 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM daily, and you can begin whenever it suits your schedule.
Is there a guided element or live support?
No, this is a completely self-guided experience. You’ll follow the app’s instructions and solve puzzles independently.
Is there a cancellation policy?
Yes, you can cancel for free up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund.
To sum it up, the Chicago Gangsters: Self-Guided Crime Story Puzzle Walk offers an engaging way to combine sightseeing with storytelling, especially if you’re comfortable with using apps and enjoy puzzles. It’s an affordable and flexible method to see some of Chicago’s most iconic spots while uncovering tales of gangsters, architecture, and resilience. Just be prepared for potential technical glitches, and you’ll have a memorable, independent urban adventure.
More Guided Tours in Chicago
- Private Chicago Street Food Walking Tour With A Local Guide
- Chicago Loop Private Walking Tour with a Guide
- Chicagos Millennium Park Self Guided Audio GPS Walking Tour
- Movie and TV Guided Walking Tour Through Chicago Union Station
- Self Guided Scavenger Hunt Lincoln Park Zoo per Scavenger Hunt
- Routes POR Route 66 with Audio Guide
More Walking Tours in Chicago
- 2 hours Private Evening Walking Tour with the Ghosts of Chicago
- Private Chicago Street Food Walking Tour With A Local Guide
- Chicago Riverwalk Architecture Walking Tour and Discover Skyline
- Chicago Loop Private Walking Tour with a Guide
- Chicagos Millennium Park Self Guided Audio GPS Walking Tour
- Lincoln Park Spirits Ghost Private Walking Tour
More Tour Reviews in Chicago
Looking for something different? Other Chicago activities we've written about
- Amazing Scavenger Hunt Time For a Go in Chicago
- Luxury Sedan O’Hare/Midway Airport (Curbside) Chicago Ony Way
- Echoes of Elegance: Chicagos Architectural Splendors
- 2 hours Private Evening Walking Tour with the Ghosts of Chicago
- Private Chicago Scavenger Hunts City Adventure
- Chicago All Day Water Taxi
- Boating or Fishing Charter Chicago’s Lake Michigan
- Chicago,Detroit,Niagara Falls,Toronto,Cleveland 4-Day Tour
- Gangs and Mobsters Crime Tour at Chicago
- Chicago Food Tour with The Magnificent Mile and Millennium Park
- Private Chicago Street Food Walking Tour With A Local Guide
- Chicago Bar Crawl: Chi-Town Showdown
