If you’re heading to New York City and want a taste of the magic that only Broadway can offer, “Just In Time” promises to be an engaging and energetic tribute to the legendary Bobby Darin. While we haven’t personally attended, the details and reviews suggest this musical combines star power, nostalgic hits, and a vibrant atmosphere—perfect for lovers of classic music and lively theater.
What really catches our eye are the stellar lead performance by Tony Award® winner Jonathan Groff, the up-close theater experience at the Circle in the Square, and the show’s celebration of iconic Bobby Darin hits like “Beyond the Sea” and “Mack the Knife.” Plus, the fact that it features a full live big band and a talented ensemble cast makes it stand out from many typical Broadway shows.
However, it’s worth noting that tickets are priced at $238.40 per person, which places it in the higher range for Broadway tickets, so you’ll want to consider whether the experience’s value aligns with your budget. This show is best suited for those who love musical biographies, nostalgic music, and the intimate vibe of a nightclub setting.
Good To Know

- Star Power: Features Tony Award® winner Jonathan Groff as Bobby Darin, offering a compelling solo performance.
- Authentic Atmosphere: Set in an intimate nightclub scene complete with a live big band, enhancing the nostalgic feel.
- Iconic Songs: Includes legendary hits like “Beyond the Sea,” “Mack the Knife,” and “Dream Lover.”
- Convenient Location: Performed at the Circle in the Square Theatre, close to public transportation.
- Duration & Accessibility: Approximately 2.5 hours long, suitable for most ages 8 and above.
- Price & Value: Tickets cost around $238, providing a rich, musical experience that emphasizes quality and authenticity.
Location and Venue
The show takes place at the Circle in the Square Theatre & School, a venue known for its intimate size and classic Broadway feel. The theatre’s proximity to public transportation makes it easy to reach, essential for an evening in NYC after a busy day of sightseeing. The venue’s layout promises an up-close experience, allowing you to feel as though you’re part of the nightclub scene that Darin would have loved.
More tours and activities we've covered in New York City
Itinerary Breakdown

Start at the theatre: Once inside, you’ll be transported into a lively, swinging nightclub. The stage is designed to evoke an authentic atmosphere reminiscent of Darin’s era—think velvet curtains, jazzy lighting, and a bustling, intimate vibe. The show is developed and directed by Tony Award winner Alex Timbers, whose flair for spectacle and energy shines through in the production.
Musical highlights: The performance features a live big band and a talented cast performing Bobby Darin’s greatest hits. Expect to hear “Beyond the Sea,” “Splish Splash,” “Dream Lover,” and “Mack the Knife.” Reviewers mention the energetic performances and the ability of the cast to recreate the nostalgic mood with authenticity and enthusiasm.
Performance style: The musical is described as exhilarating, with a focus on storytelling through Darin’s music and life. The cast’s engaging delivery, combined with Groff’s charismatic portrayal of Darin, makes for a memorable show.
Audience engagement: Since the theatre is small and intimate, you’ll notice the performers’ interactions feel personal rather than distant. This proximity amplifies the emotional impact of the music and storytelling.
Additional Details from Reviews

Some reviewers have highlighted the impressive cast and the high-quality direction. One pointed out the “stellar ensemble cast” and how the show captures the “swing nightclub” vibe, creating an immersive experience. Others appreciated the choice of songs and the way they are woven into the narrative, making the concert feel both nostalgic and fresh.
However, a few noted that the ticket prices are on the higher side, but many felt the experience justified the cost due to the quality of the performance and the intimacy of the venue.
Practical Considerations

- Duration: Approximately 2 hours 30 minutes, including potentially an intermission.
- Age suitability: Recommended for ages 8 and above; younger children under 8 are not permitted.
- Accessibility: For those with special seating needs, it’s advised to contact customer service in advance.
- Tickets: Best available seats are assigned at the time of purchase, and tickets will be delivered no later than two weeks before the show, so plan accordingly.
If you’re someone who appreciates the golden age of American music or enjoys shows with a nostalgic vibe, “Just In Time” is a compelling choice. The combination of a live band, intimate setting, and powerful performances promises a memorable night. The focus on Bobby Darin’s hits makes it especially appealing for fans of classic jazz, swing, and pop.
While the ticket price may seem steep, many reviews suggest that the quality of production, the authenticity of the music, and the engaging performances make it worth considering. It’s a chance to experience Broadway with a musical that celebrates American musical icons in a style that feels both genuine and lively.
This experience suits those seeking a sophisticated night out, fans of musical biographies, or anyone looking to add a touch of jazz-age glamour to their NYC adventure. Its intimate venue and energetic cast make it a show that’s likely to resonate, even long after curtain call.
“Just In Time” offers a fresh yet nostalgic look at Bobby Darin’s life through the power of music and storytelling. The show’s live big band, up-close setting, and stellar cast provide a high-quality theatrical experience that’s ideal for music lovers and Broadway enthusiasts alike.
While the price tag is on the higher side, the premium experience—a blend of nostalgia, great performances, and an authentic nightclub atmosphere—can certainly justify the investment. It’s particularly well-suited for those who want a more personal and lively musical experience rather than a large-scale spectacle.
If you’re looking for a night of lively music, engaging storytelling, and a taste of the golden era, this show could be just what you need to cap off a busy day exploring NYC’s iconic sights.
Is the ticket price of $238.40 per person worth it?
Considering the intimate setting, live big band, and high-quality performances, many find the ticket price justified for a memorable Broadway experience that combines music and storytelling effectively.
How long is the show?
The performance lasts approximately 2 hours and 30 minutes, including potential intermission, which is typical for Broadway musicals.
Can I buy tickets close to the performance date?
Tickets are delivered no later than 2 weeks before the show, so it’s best to book in advance to secure the best available seats.
Is the show suitable for children?
Yes, it is recommended for ages 8 and above. Children under 8 are not permitted in the theatre.
What is the venue, and how accessible is it?
The show is at the Circle in the Square Theatre, known for its intimate atmosphere and close proximity to public transportation. For accessible seating, you should contact customer service beforehand.
What are some of the songs performed?
Expect to hear Bobby Darin classics such as “Beyond the Sea,” “Splish Splash,” “Dream Lover,” and “Mack the Knife.”
Is there a dress code?
There is no strict dress code, but smart casual or Broadway-style attire is appropriate for the occasion.
How can I ensure I have good seats?
Seats are assigned at the time of purchase based on availability, and the best seats are generally those closest to the stage. Booking early can help secure a better spot.
This musical promises a lively, intimate, and nostalgic evening in New York City, perfect for music fans and Broadway lovers who want something a little different from the usual.
More Tickets in New York City
- 9/11 World Trade Center Walking Tour with Museum Tickets
- American Museum of Natural History Admission Ticket
- American Dream Sesame Street Learn + Play Ticket
- Combo Ticket Top of the Rock Observatory and MOMA
- FRIENDS in New York City Private Car Tour with Tickets
- Heathers: The Musical Off-Broadway Show Ticket
More Tour Reviews in New York City
Looking for something different? Other New York City activities we've written about
- 10 Passenger Van from Times Square to EWR Newark Airport
- Statue of Liberty Boat Party in NYC
- Private Pedicab Guided Tour in New York City
- 2 hour – Private Gangsters and Ghosts Vintage Car Tour
- 2 Hours Private Guided Tour
- 2 Hour Private Mixology Cocktail Class
- Pedicab 2 Hour Central Park Tour
- Indian Temple and Chinese Garden Tour
- A Complete Unknown Movie Sites Private Tour
- 3 Day Niagara Falls and Philadelphia Tour from New York
- 3 Course Italian Lunch at Broadway Fave Bond 45 in Times Square!
- VIP Gossip Girl Tour
