NYC: Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos.

When it comes to nightlife experiences in New York City, most visitors seek something that combines entertainment with a touch of exclusivity. The Five Star Dining. All-Star Dueling Pianos tour offers just that—an evening immersed in lively music, delicious food, and a vibe that feels both intimate and electric. This experience is hosted at NYC’s top steak and seafood restaurant, tucked away inside the legendary Hunt and Fish Club, inside the AKA Times Square Hotel.

What makes this evening stand out? First, you get to enjoy the longest running dueling pianos show in NYC history—a true testament to its popularity and quality. Second, the venue is an underground secret, adding a special sense of exclusivity. Third, the menu is said to be some of the finest in the city, with crafted cocktails, designer burgers, and even their famous bread. The main potential consideration? It’s a ticketed event with a $40 minimum spend, so it’s more than just the show; it’s a full dining experience.

This tour is perfect for travelers who love live music, enjoy good food, and aren’t shy about singing along or requesting their favorite tracks. If you’re after a lively, memorable night with a fun crowd and great eats, this experience might be just what you need.

Good To Know

• Exclusive underground setting creates a unique vibe for the show.
• Long-standing reputation with the longest-running dueling pianos show in NYC.
• Flexible song requests with thousands of options, ensuring a personalized experience.
• High-quality menu featuring prime steak, seafood, designer burgers, and acclaimed bread.
• Requires a $40 food/minimum and gratuity for performers, but adds to the value of a fully curated night.
• Limited tickets make this an intimate event perfect for those seeking a special night out.

You can check if your dates are available here:

An In-Depth Look at the Experience

The Venue and Atmosphere

The event takes place in a secret underground showroom within the Hunt and Fish Club, a restaurant renowned for its top-tier steak and seafood. This hidden setting amps up the exclusivity; you’re not just in a bustling Times Square restaurant but in a dedicated, intimate space designed for entertainment. Reviewers mention that check-in at the host stand is straightforward, and the seating is reserved for your group, starting at 7 pm. The show kicks off at 8:30 pm, allowing plenty of time for a leisurely dinner and drinks.

The atmosphere is lively yet sophisticated, perfect for couples, groups of friends, or even a special date night. The venue’s design, combined with the energetic piano duels, creates an environment that feels polished but casual enough to sing, dance, and have fun.

The Dueling Pianos Show

This isn’t just a standard piano performance. With thousands of songs to choose from, you’re encouraged to request your favorites—rock, pop, classics, or even guilty pleasures. Reviewers have appreciated how “never the same show twice,” with interactive singing and laughter making for a dynamic experience. The hosts and pianists are described as engaging, talented, and skilled at reading the room, ensuring everyone feels included.

The show’s history as the longest-running dueling pianos act in NYC underlines its professionalism and appeal. Guests have noted that the performers keep the energy high, responding to song requests with enthusiasm, and creating a festive, party-like vibe.

The Menu and Drinks

The restaurant itself has a reputation for delivering high-quality cuisine, which is a key part of the experience. The menu features famous bread, crafted cocktails, and designer burgers—a step above typical bar fare. While the price of the ticket doesn’t include food or drinks, it does include a $40 minimum spend per guest, which can be on food, drinks, or both.

Guests have praised the quality of the food, mentioning that the steak and seafood options are top-notch, and the cocktails are thoughtfully crafted. You’ll want to arrive hungry and ready to indulge, as the menu adds significant value to the ticket price. Keep in mind that a 20% service charge is added on-site, typical for NYC fine dining.

More Great Thing To Do Nearby

What to Expect

Your evening begins with check-in and reserved table seating, with the show starting around 8:30 pm. You can arrive at 7 pm to enjoy your meal and drinks beforehand. Once seated, the performers will start taking requests, and the night’s entertainment will revolve around sing-alongs, humorous banter, and lively piano duels.

While the core experience is the interactive music and entertainment, the quality of the food and drinks elevates the night further. The venue’s atmosphere encourages guests to participate actively, whether singing a favorite tune or cheering on the performers.

Practical Details and Tips

• Limit of 50 tickets makes this a more intimate experience—book early if you want to secure your spot.
• Tickets are held at will call, so make sure to arrive on time for a smooth check-in.
• The event typically lasts around 4 hours, making it a substantial evening outing.
• The recommended dress code leans towards smart casual—think nice jeans or a dress shirt, but nothing overly formal.
• Payment is flexible, with options to reserve now and pay later, offering better planning for your trip.
• Remember to bring credit cards, cash, and IDs; no smoking allowed, and children under 16 are not permitted.

Why This Experience Is Worth It

The appeal of this tour lies in its blend of live entertainment, gourmet dining, and exclusivity. For those seeking a night that feels both upscale and fun, it ticks all boxes. The interactive nature of the show makes it a memorable outing—songs you request, laughter with the crowd, and a lively, party atmosphere.

On top of that, the long-standing reputation and positive reviews suggest that this isn’t just a flash-in-the-pan event but a well-established highlight of NYC nightlife. The venue’s underground setting adds a layer of intrigue, making it a perfect choice for a special celebration or simply a unique night out.

Who Is This Best For?

This experience suits music lovers, foodies, and those wanting a memorable night with friends, family, or a partner. It’s also ideal if you’re after a more intimate, exclusive setting rather than a large concert or tourist-packed event. If you enjoy interactive shows, singing your favorite songs, and trying high-quality food in a lively environment, you’ll love what this experience has to offer.

FAQ

Is this experience suitable for children?
No, children under 16 are not allowed, as the environment is geared toward adults and includes alcohol service.

How long does the event last?
The entire experience runs about 4 hours, starting with dinner at 7 pm, and the show begins at 8:30 pm.

What is included in the ticket price?
Your ticket grants access to the show and reserved table seating. You must meet a $40 food and beverage minimum, plus gratuity for performers and a 20% service charge.

Can I request specific songs?
Yes! The show features thousands of songs, and you’re encouraged to request your favorites to be sung and played live.

Are drinks included?
No, drinks are not included but are available for purchase. The menu has crafted cocktails and high-quality beverages.

Is there a dress code?
Smart casual is appropriate—think neat, comfortable, and stylish attire.

How do I get my tickets?
Tickets are held at will call, so you just need to check in at the host stand with your reservation.

What if I need to cancel?
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, offering flexibility if your plans change.

Is the venue accessible?
The experience description doesn’t specify accessibility features, but the venue is inside a hotel, which suggests some level of accessibility. It’s best to check directly if needed.

Where exactly is the event located?
Inside the Hunt and Fish Club at 125 W 44th St, inside the AKA Times Square Hotel, hidden in an underground showroom.

Final Thoughts

This tour offers a lively, upscale way to spend an evening in New York City. Combining top-tier food, interactive live music, and an exclusive underground setting, it appeals to those looking for a memorable, fun night out. The longstanding reputation, positive reviews, and intimate atmosphere make it a solid choice for travelers eager for a different NYC experience.

While the ticket price might seem higher than standard dinner shows, the quality of food, entertainment, and the unique venue create real value. Keep in mind the minimum spend requirement and plan accordingly, but know that you’re paying for a night that’s both highly entertaining and delicious.

Perfect for music fans, food lovers, and those celebrating special occasions, this experience offers a taste of NYC’s lively, sophisticated nightlife scene in a way that’s both authentic and memorable.

Whether you’re a music enthusiast or simply looking for a night of fun and good food, this dueling pianos experience is bound to leave you smiling.

You can check if your dates are available here: