New York: Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live

Looking for an evening filled with laughs and genuine entertainment in the heart of Manhattan? The Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live show has become a popular choice for visitors wanting to enjoy NYC’s vibrant comedy scene without breaking the bank. While we haven’t personally attended, reviews and official info paint a picture of a lively, intimate, and comedy-packed experience that’s perfect for those craving a dose of humor after sightseeing or a night out on the town.

What makes this show stand out? First, it features comics seen on Netflix, Hulu, and Saturday Night Live, so you’re getting performances from some of the most recognizable and talented comedians in the industry. Second, the venue’s close seating creates an intimate atmosphere that lets you really feel part of the action. Third, the location near Times Square means you’re in the thick of the Broadway Theater District, making it easy to add to your evening plans. However, one thing to keep in mind is that a two-drink minimum is enforced, which can add up, especially if you’re just there for the laughs and not the drinks.

This experience is best suited for adults and older teens who enjoy stand-up comedy and are okay with a lively, sometimes loud, atmosphere. If you’re after a relaxed, family-friendly show, this might not be the best fit. Overall, it’s a great way to see talented comedians in a cozy setting and experience a genuine piece of New York’s comedy culture.

• TV comedians: Performers are from well-known platforms like Netflix and Hulu.
• Intimate setting: All seats are close to the stage, enhancing the experience.
• Prime location: Near Times Square and the Broadway Theater District.
• Value for money: Tickets are around $25, offering a budget-friendly comedy show.
• Drinks policy: Two drinks minimum, with a range of alcoholic and non-alcoholic options.
• Surprise drop-ins: Expect occasional guest comics that keep things fresh.

The Broadway Comedy Club is renowned for its up-close-and-personal seating arrangement, which is a real plus for comedy lovers. You won’t be sitting miles away from the stage here; instead, you’re likely to find yourself almost on top of the performers, creating that perfect, front-row feeling. Several reviews mention the intimate vibe—guests feel more connected to the comedians and the overall show.

The venue itself has a casual, laid-back atmosphere, making it a perfect spot to unwind after a day of sightseeing. However, some reviewers have noted that the appearance of the venue could benefit from some sprucing up, suggesting it looks a little tired or in need of a fresh coat of paint. Still, this doesn’t detract from the core experience, which is the comedy and the lively crowd.

What truly sets this show apart is the caliber of comedians. The lineup includes top headliners from New York City, many of whom have appeared on major platforms like Comedy Central, HBO, and Amazon. Reviewers consistently mention that the opening acts are particularly strong, with some describing them as “amazing” and “brilliant.” Others note that while a few acts may not hit the mark every time, the overall quality remains high.

Expect a mix of established comedians and emerging talent. Several reviews praise the hosts and MCs for their professionalism and quick wit, which helps keep the energy high and the audience engaged. Surprises are common—sometimes comedians drop in for impromptu stage time, adding an element of unpredictability that many find exciting.

The show lasts about 1.5 hours, sometimes stretching slightly longer, which is typical for comedy performances. You should arrive up to 30 minutes early to get settled and avoid missing any of the action. Once inside, you’ll be greeted at the box office by staff who are described as friendly and helpful.

While the ticket price of around $25 is quite reasonable, be aware of the two-drink minimum—this is standard practice, but some reviewers remember paying over $11 for a beer. Drinks include both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options, with a variety of choices, though some mention that beers tend to be more affordable than spirits.

The performance is lively and loud, with a casual, fun vibe. Audience members sit in close proximity, which means there’s a lot of interaction and banter. Some reviews mention having to deal with disruptive guests, like a drunk woman who came up on stage, but staff seemed to manage such situations with a sense of humor.

• Arrive early to secure the best seats and avoid the crowded entry.
• Be prepared for the 2 drink minimum; consider ordering drinks early if you plan to indulge.
• If you’re sensitive to loud environments, note that the show can be energetic and lively.
• It’s not suitable for children under 12, so plan accordingly.
• Expect a show that may run slightly longer than scheduled, so plan your evening accordingly.
• Take note of the venue’s somewhat casual decor, which might not be “Instagram-perfect,” but doesn’t take away from the fun.
• Since the comedians and lineup can change nightly, check if particular acts are scheduled if you want to see specific performers.

At $25 per ticket, this comedy show offers excellent value, especially considering the chance to see TV-star comedians in an intimate venue. The two-drink minimum might seem like an added expense, but it’s typical for comedy clubs and offers the chance to relax with a drink while enjoying the show.

Many reviews mention the quality of the comedians, some of whom have appeared in major comedy festivals or on national TV. The good mix of established acts and new talent ensures that you get a diverse comedy experience for your money. While drinks can be pricey—some guests mention paying $11 for a Stella—this is typical for NYC and should be factored into your budget.

The Broadway Comedy Club is wheelchair accessible, making it accessible for most guests with mobility needs. Its central location near Times Square makes it an ideal stop for those already exploring NYC’s bustling theater district.

Getting there is straightforward, with many nearby subway stations and easy access via taxis or rideshare. The venue is also within walking distance from major hotels and tourist hotspots, making it a convenient addition to a night in Manhattan.

One thing many guests appreciate is the authentic NYC comedy vibe. You’re not watching a polished Hollywood production; you’re witnessing real comedians testing out new material in a relaxed, no-frills environment. Several reviews mention surprise guest comedians dropping in, adding a fresh twist to each show.

While some audience members note that not every joke lands, the overall atmosphere remains upbeat, and the lively crowd keeps the energy high. The mix of local New Yorkers and travelers creates a dynamic and friendly environment.

In the end, the Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live show is an excellent choice if you want a fun, affordable, and authentic comedy experience in New York City. You’ll enjoy close-up performances by comedians seen on TV, in a venue that fosters a lively and intimate vibe. The location near Times Square makes it easy to fit into your busy NYC itinerary.

This show is especially perfect for stand-up comedy fans eager for a taste of New York’s comedy scene without spending a fortune. It’s also a good option for group outings or date nights, offering plenty of laughs and casual fun. Just remember the drink policy and expect some variability in the lineups.

This comedy show is best for adults and older teens looking for a relaxed, humorous night out. If you enjoy TV comedians and stand-up, you’ll likely love the quality and energy of the acts presented here. Travelers who want a cost-effective entertainment option close to the heart of Manhattan will find this a great way to unwind after a day of sightseeing.

If you’re after a family-friendly, quiet evening, or prefer more polished, theatrical comedy, other options might suit you better. However, if a raw, lively, and authentic NYC comedy experience sounds appealing, this show will deliver plenty of laughs and memorable moments.

Is there a dress code for the comedy show?
No formal dress code is required. Most guests dress casually, reflecting the relaxed atmosphere of the venue.

Can I purchase tickets at the door?
Yes, tickets can usually be purchased at the box office. However, booking in advance is recommended to secure your spot, especially during busy times.

How long is the show?
The show lasts approximately 1.5 hours, but it can run a few minutes longer depending on the lineup and any surprise guest comedians.

Are drinks included in the ticket price?
No, tickets include entry only. There is a two-drink minimum per guest, with both alcoholic and non-alcoholic options available for purchase.

Is the venue wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the Broadway Comedy Club is wheelchair accessible, making it suitable for most guests with mobility needs.

What is the seating like?
All seats are close to the stage, creating an intimate comedy experience. Some reviews mention that seating can be a little crowded, but it contributes to the lively vibe.

Are children allowed at the show?
The show is not suitable for children under 12, so plan accordingly if you’re bringing teenagers.

Can I see specific comedians?
Lineups vary from night to night, and while many performers are well-known, check the schedule if you have specific acts in mind. Surprise drop-ins are common.

What if I need to cancel?
You can cancel up to 24 hours in advance for a full refund, providing flexibility for your plans.

The Broadway Comedy Club All Star Stand-Up Comedy Live offers an affordable and authentic taste of NYC’s comedy scene. Its intimate setting, high-quality lineups, and central location make it a lively and memorable option for travelers wanting to enjoy a night of laughter. While drinks can add to the expense, the fun and entertainment are well worth the cost for most guests. If you’re eager to see comedians who’ve appeared on TV and enjoy a casual, energetic atmosphere, this show is a clear winner. It’s a fantastic way to add some humor to your New York adventure and experience the city’s vibrant comedic spirit firsthand.

You can check if your dates are available here: